If you could sum up an entire story in one image, it would be the monthly recurring revenue graph for ConvertKit. So if you want the short version of the last 2 years of my work, just look at this image:
Now I’d like to share the behind the scenes stories that explain exactly what happened and what every curve of that chart means.
2 years, 2 months, and 9 days ago I announced my big new goal for the year: to start a brand new SaaS company and grow it to $5,000 in monthly recurring revenue within 6 months. The other catch is that I could only make an initial investment of $5,000.
I called this The Web App Challenge and you can read the announcement post here.
You can also go back and read the posts I wrote as I worked through the challenge. If you don’t want to read through the entire history I’ll sum it up here:
I decided to solve my email marketing frustrations and build a tool that had all the email marketing best practices I was using to sell hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of books built in by default. That tool is called ConvertKit.
Things didn’t work out as planned
Unfortunately July 1st, 2013 arrived and ConvertKit was only at $2,480/month. Basically half of where I needed to be. At first I thought, “Oh well, we’ll continue to grow and hit our goal in a few more months.” Unfortunately that didn’t happen. ConvertKit revenue stayed steady and then gradually declined. $2,480 was the peak month.
Note: this was actually based on an estimate of what the month would be (with payments from multiple sources), not final numbers (it was before I had Baremetrics). The actual numbers were closer to $2,000.
But I made it to that number only having spent slightly more than my initial $5,000 investment and another ~$5,000 that we brought in from customers.
When things didn’t work out as planned, I focused back on my books. By this time I had three books out that were all selling very well. I was making over $15,000-25,000 from book sales each month so that’s where I started focusing my energy.
I still worked on ConvertKit, but the limited effort I put into it didn’t result in any growth.
Summer 2014 I experimented with selling SaaS like an info-product by launching ConvertKit Academy. It was initially very successful ($7,000 in revenue in one month), but then seats stopped selling and I once again lost motivation.
Even though ConvertKit Academy didn’t turn out to be as financially sustainable as I’d hoped, it was still a good experiment which helped dozens of people start their email lists.
The wrong audience
Unfortunately the focus on education—particularly building a list from scratch—attracted an audience that didn’t make the best customers. What we found is that these beginners complained the most about price, lacked the discipline to produce content consistently, and were very likely to cancel when their project failed.
On top of that the focus on beginners alienated some people who would have been much better customers – people who already had serious online businesses wondered if ConvertKit was right for them. We were actually driving away our best customers and focusing on those least likely to succeed.
In October 2014 monthly recurring revenue had slid all the way down to $1,207. Something had to change.
Treating ConvertKit as a side project just wasn’t working. The rest of my business (book and course sales) were doing great, but ConvertKit was sliding further towards zero revenue. And it still cost a decent amount to run each month.
I had to make a decision. Either give ConvertKit the attention it deserved or shut it down (or put it on auto-pilot). Fully shutting down ConvertKit wasn’t really an option. It was an incredibly powerful tool that I had built for exactly my needs. It was the tool that enabled me to grow my list to over 30,000 email subscribers so quickly.
Putting it on auto-pilot was an option. That would mean continuing to run it for existing customers, but not actively market it or develop new features.
Or I could double down on ConvertKit and give it the time and energy it deserved to see if it could be successful. I thought long and hard about this. I had one direction that I could still try. I decided it was time to double down on ConvertKit and give it every possible opportunity to succeed.
Email marketing for _______
Who is ConvertKit for? That was a question that I never had a really good answer for. The answer was something like, “anyone trying to build an audience quickly and sell products online.”
That’s not good. Here’s a hint: if your market definition has the word “anyone” in it, you’ll probably fail.
Since writing and publishing Authority I’ve watched readers launch hundreds of books. One trend is that the more specific the book topic and audience, the more money it will make. In other words, “Introduction to Design” is not going to do nearly as well as a specific guide to something specific like software onboarding.
In other words, be specific.
Do what I say…
I’ve given this advice dozens of times and saved plenty of readers from writing generic books that are practically guaranteed to fail.
Despite giving that advice I made the exact same mistake. ConvertKit wasn’t messaged to a specific segment of the market, and as a result, no one thought it was exactly for them.
Another case of do what I say, not what I do.
With the advice from a few friends I decided to focus heavily on one market and change all the messaging to match. We wouldn’t turn away customers from outside the market, but this would give us a focused audience to pursue.
Email marketing for authors
The segment we chose was email marketing for authors. One trend I saw among our most successful customers was that they wrote and sold books or courses to their audience – just like me. I built ConvertKit with my exact use-case in mind: it’s the perfect tool to sell more books and courses.
This new direction, combined with full-time work on the product, reversed the downward trend of revenue. By the end of October MRR had grown 23% to $1,646.
Then in November we continued to execute on the same strategy and grew 27% up to $2,100.
Around this time I also started doing direct sales. Previously if I talked to someone at a conference and they expressed interest in ConvertKit, I’d talk to them and then try to remember to follow-up later.
I’m sure you spotted the problem with that already: I’d try to remember. I didn’t write it down, track the conversation, or anything else.
But finally I changed that and started tracking every conversation in a ConvertKit Sales Trello board.
While at MicroConf, Ryan Delk and I were talking with another attendee who expressed interest in ConvertKit. We talked for a while about how he could best use it. After we finished our conversation, I pulled out my phone, opened Trello (their iOS app is really good), and added the person I’d been speaking with to the “Interested” column on the ConvertKit sales board.
Ryan’s only comment was, “I’ve been trying to get you to do that for over a year.”
The focus on authors also enabled us to start reaching out to potential customers. Since technical authors did well with ConvertKit, we contacted all the top sellers on LeanPub and Udemy. Out of about a hundred personal emails, we picked up 5-7 customers. Not great, but also not bad. Especially for this early stage.
I found it interesting to learn that even the top LeanPub authors aren’t actually making that much money, whereas the top Udemy authors are doing very well.
December was the month all this effort really started to come together. MRR grew 54% to $3,237. I started to get very encouraged about where things were headed.
And because of a couple annual prepayments net revenue was even higher at $4,480.
All these new customers meant a lot of feature requests. And I was starting to notice the flaws and little frustrations in the product. In order to make ConvertKit truly great we would need a full-time team focusing on it.
Dan was already on the team, mostly working on my books and courses, but over this time he switched over to focusing full-time on ConvertKit support. Marc was working about half-time on our development, but he was also busy with other projects.
To build the big features like marketing automation, we needed to add a full-time developer.
But that costs money that ConvertKit didn’t have. In order to support growth over the past couple months I’d been funneling a bit of money from my books and courses into ConvertKit to make up for our increased expenses. Now that I wanted to bring on a full-time developer I’d need to make that official with a larger investment.
So on January 1st, 2014 I invested $50,000 into ConvertKit. The next day my good friend David Wheeler joined the company as lead developer. David and I have worked together on a bunch of projects over the last 5 or 6 years. Whenever I need a designer or developer, he’s the first person I turn to.
I honestly didn’t think I’d be able to hire him away from his current gig, but circumstances worked out perfectly and I’m incredibly lucky to have him on the team.
Though, the new expenses did add stress. Hilary and I trimmed our personal expenses to the minimum, I ended the lease on my office and moved my computers and camera gear back home, and we cut back the extra money we were paying on our mortgage each month.
Since we had spent so much money buying and remodeling our house, our personal accounts were the lowest they’d been in years. In fact, that $50,000 investment represented the last bit of our large cash reserves from the year before.
We decided that focusing this way would make 2015 a lean year for our personal finances, but it would be worth it in order to build ConvertKit into a sustainable company.
Record growth and then a slump
The beginning of January we landed a few big new accounts and MRR kept climbing. From December 15th to January 15th we grew 60% to $4,067.
That’s great! Except that’s not the entire month of January. If we look at the entire month things don’t look as good:
On January 18th I went on a 2 week trip to Thailand to visit family. The trip was an amazing experience and I felt blessed to be able to travel like that.
At the same time being away in remote parts of the world taught me two things:
1. The team I have in place to run ConvertKit is truly world-class.
Several major things went wrong at a time that I was on a remote island trying to make sure my stuff didn’t get stolen by monkeys. Dan, Marc, and David fixed everything and communicated with customers perfectly without any involvement from me. That’s a founders dream come true.
2. Growth stalls out when I go on vacation. We still hit 20% growth in January, but that’s only because the first 15 days were so good. We ended the month with lower MRR than we had on the 15th. My hope was that growth would continue, though I didn’t expect it to at the same rate. But I learned that I need to get better systems in place for sales.
Getting back on track
February had a slow start, but growth picked up and we closed the month growing 17% to $4,561.
A messaging problem
In January I started to notice a problem with “Email marketing for authors.” Our customers that most strongly identified with the term “author” tended to be on the smallest accounts, needed the most help, and were the most likely to cancel. In other words, they were hobbyist authors. Not professionals.
Somewhere in that time Dan and I realized that our best customers didn’t start building an email list from scratch, instead they switched their list over from another provider. These people usually didn’t strongly identify themselves as authors. Instead they were bloggers, course creators, or something else. I didn’t know what to call them.
But the feedback was pretty strong from my one-on-one conversations: the people who had the potential to be our best customers saw “email marketing for authors” and thought it wasn’t for them.
David spent the beginning of the year working on marketing automation, which totally changed ConvertKit’s capabilities. Before these automation features, you could do a lot with Zapier, but the process was clunky. Now, marketing automation is built directly into ConvertKit, and the user experience is 10x better.
With our powerful triggers and actions you can build a fully automated marketing and sales funnel. We’ll announce more about this soon.
Our dedication to a great UX is best summed up by our Gumroad integration.
You can now move purchasers from Gumroad into ConvertKit and add them to a course or form in 47 seconds. Seriously, that’s how good it is. You can set it all up that quickly. Watch this video:
That makes ConvertKit the only email marketing provider to have a direct Gumroad integration. If you use Gumroad to sell products and/or courses, we should talk.
I spent last weekend up in the mountains of North Carolina for a mastermind retreat with Barrett, Caleb, Matthew, and James. In a 90 minute session we focused entirely on ConvertKit. We talked messaging, growth, and other strategies.
The key takeaways were that we would:
- Rebrand ConvertKit to be “Email marketing for Professional Bloggers”. That statement best represented our best customers. The authors page is still available at /authors, but it no longer has the focus of our home page.
- Focus even more on direct sales. Talk to professional bloggers with lists of 30,000 to 250,000 subscribers to up their marketing game and switch to ConvertKit.
- Continue to provide incredible support and concierge migrations to move these professional bloggers over to ConvertKit and help them grow their lists faster and sell more products. That’s what we’re best at.
- Continue to feature our favorite customers. They do amazing things and we want to do a better job showcasing their work.
I made it home late Monday night with perfect clarity on what I needed to spend my time doing and who our target customers are. That’s an amazing feeling.
Meeting the goal
Then something happened that I’ve been working towards for 2 years, 2 months, and 9 days: we passed $5,000 in monthly recurring revenue.
Based on the conversations I’m having now we should continue growing quite quickly.
Obviously with the team we have in place now and current expenses, ConvertKit isn’t profitable. Our burn rate is now about $8,000 per month, not including my own salary.
Breaking the rules
Originally I set out two rules for The Web App Challenge:
- Grow to $5,000 in MRR in 6 months.
- Do it with only $5,000 in investment.
I didn’t hit either of those. Instead of 6 months it took 26. And instead of investing just $5,000 in ConvertKit, I’ve invested $55,000.
But instead of giving up along the way, I pushed through what was a long, hard journey and met the ultimate goal: $5k in MRR.
This is just the beginning. Now with a great team on board we’ll continue to grow to become profitable. I know exactly the steps that need to be taken in order to make that happen.
If you make your living from your blog, we should talk. ConvertKit was tailor made for people just like you and me. Plus, we’ll handle the entire migration for you and set you up with marketing best practices along the way.
Here’s to the next 2 years, 2 months, and 9 days.
35 Responses to “Growing ConvertKit to $5,020 in Monthly Recurring Revenue”
I love these types of posts. Thanks for sharing and inspiring and helping others.
Amazing story Nathan! I’ve been following it from the very beginning. Congratulations!
Wow, I really needed to read this exactly right now.
I’m glad it helped! Hope things are going well for you.
Great to see you chronicle your journey! You know the next $5K will be different right?! ;) Happy to chat about strategies to get you there.
We should definitely talk again soon.
Hey Nathan; Great stuff mate. I too have set myself a goal for generating a new 5K per month recurring income in an upcoming product. We should organise a time to chat about web apps etc. I was recently on SPI sharing how I brought one of my latest products to life with 30k in pre sales. http://www.smartpassiveincome.com/product-validation-and-pre-selling-with-jarrod-robinson/
Congrats Nathan! 5K is an amazing milestone and if you keep up this pace it’s only a matter of time until ConvertKit reaches 10K in recurring revenue.
And by the way, I really love your writing style. As matter of fact your posts have had a huge impact in motivating me to get started with writing my very own e-book. I’ll reach out sometime via email to share more details about that ;-)
I love your transparency and persistance Nathan. I didn’t ‘get’ convertkit when I first saw it as it melted into the field of other autoresponders (for me). I think sub niching down like that and following it through plus your awesome UX skills (yes I have your book) you are on to a winner.
Nathan, congratulations on reaching your goal! I, too, was following the challenge from the very beginning. Appreciate the honest analysis of what went wrong, especially the Wrong Audience section – this really hit home with me. Thank you for sharing.
I often hear stories from failure to success and it also sounds like a clear path. I am glad you wrote this because it mimics my experience in the online world as well.
Nice write-up on your challenges, changes, and growth Nathan! Congrats on what you guys have accomplished so far!
P.S. Stealing your Trello board setup :- )
My favorite part about this entire post is that it doesn’t end with… “And then we started making $10,000,000 MRR!!!” Because that’s the truth. That’s the real journey for most of us. It’s hard damn work and these stories are typically only shared after major success (not during the middle).
Kudos for the transparency as always. I’m sure you can get to $10M MRR in no time at all :)
Thanks Jason! We still have a long way to go.
This is awesome, Nathan! Thanks a lot for sharing.
Funnily enough, I’m one of your “small, just getting started author” clients – but hopefully still adding value by spreading the word to other authors!
I think what matters is less if and how you broke the rules, but rather whether or not you’re upping your game and adding incredible value to the entire online marketplace — which you clearly are!
Sort of, but you have a good idea of what you want and how to get there. We feel like we’re helping you achieve your goals. For the customers I’m referring to it feels more like babysitting.
I think you should go a step further and re-word the “email marketing” part too. Mailchimp can do “email marketing”, why would this tiny product do it better than Mailchimp? Don’t explain it to me; I’m just demonstrating that this question shouldn’t even be coming up.
The classic advice you’ve heard is “benefits, not features”. So “audience growth for …”, “retention”, “engagement”, heck put “revenue” in there somewhere.
Interesting thought, but I disagree. The product still needs to fit with existing mental models people have.
Nice job man. Glad you didn’t throw in the towel :)
Me too. :)
Another awesome post Nathan!! Thank you very much for sharing your journey. I was following you all along beginning from day one of this jounrey. Its very encouraging to see that you are on track and that only happened because you didn’t give up but moved forward with persistence and believing in your product and by focusing on who your true customer is. I wish you all the best in making ConvertKit into a sustainable company.
Hey Nathan, thank you so much for sharing this fascinating behind-the-scenes look at ConvertKit!
I’m one of the people that’s been considering using ConvertKit for a while but didn’t quite identify with the “author” label, even though I sell infoproducts, some in ebook form.
Here comes a completely unsolicited idea:
I noticed your remarketing FB ads but since I didn’t think I was a good fit for the software, I mostly ignored them. They kept you top of mind, of course, but they weren’t going to convince me of anything.
What if you ran remarketing ads with a call-to-action that got people to tell them their objections to ConvertKit, or why they were on the fence? I’ve done that for my own program where I got people to just answer a two question survey about why they were on the fence about my program and then I got back to them via email.
Now I know you said that growth slows down when you’re not hustling to bring in more people, and this strategy wouldn’t fix that – it would probably depend on engagement with you – but I can’t help but think that if I had had a short email exchange with you a few months ago (or if this post had existed back then), my doubts would have been addressed and I would have seen ConvertKit WAS actually a good fit me.
Does that make sense?
Anyway, looking forward to checking out these news features!
Really fantastic post. Congrats on sticking with it and consistently taking a step beside yourself to objectively evaluate the vision, positioning, and viability of the opportunity.
No matter what, your openness regarding this “adventure” is admirable.
However, although most of your previous articles are about how you made it, with this one it’s not very clear what one should take away with him/her. The challenge you set yourself was clearly not successful, then you basically just invested 10 times the initial amount to keep the service running and you are still not making any profits.
I hope my tone is not aggressive, I am only wondering if you wanted to “share a message” along with documenting your progress on the open.
Excellent transparency and contrats on the success. You have stayed on your grind and it is paying off. Constantly identifing additional value and technique to market and moving forward. Props Nathan, I don’t subscribe to maybe blogs – maybe 3 and you are one of my favorites. Keep doing what you do, I’ll be launching my eBook soon and it is exciting.
Thanks for sharing your way on such a detailed level.
Awesome story, Nathan.
Strangely, it is more inspiring with the hardship in it, than a pure success piece.
This high-touch sales seem to be a departure from your other products. Where did you learn how to do it? An article on your sales process will be great, for most of us that haven’t done it.
Man, you are awesome.
Trying a lot of things like me. Never giving up.
All the best :)
Thanks for this! Good stuff! And good luck on the next 5K!
Awesome stuff Nathan. Congrats on reaching your MRR goal! I wouldn’t bet against you. I’m amazed that your burn rate is only $8,000/month with a team of 3. Crazy.
Truly inspiring ! I love reading these types of post. Great job !
Nathan- great article and gave me some ideas to apply to my business- I think it is always great when people share what DIDN’T work and WHY.
Your article hammers home a few BIG ideas:
A) conversations with your client base are KEY to identify proper marketing. Not knowing your customer is working blindly.
B) Leave ego at the door and be willing to rebrand as necessary.
C)Startups always take 5-10X more time and 5-10x more $$ than we plan. Forget who said this but it is almost always true.
Good luck and best wishes for continued growth and success in ’15 and beyond.
Great article, but just curious if you have tested something like first month free (like your competitors do)… it may just be that you’re mainly attracting people moving an already established list over because you’re really not an option for someone just starting out. The only real path for someone to come to you is to use one of the other sites first, get disenchanted, move (which makes it harder for affiliates to sell you too). I think you’re missing out on a lot of natural growth with your high price point for someone starting from scratch.
I really like your transparency, Nathan. And how you talked about the personal sacrifices you and your wife had made to make this goal a reality. Very genuine.
I know this is old but super relevant for me. Thanks, Nathan for sharing.